The Best Approach Shoes of 2024

82 views 8:24 pm 0 Comments January 2, 2024

From the car to the cliff, a good pair of approach shoes can help you reach your rocky objective in style. Approach shoes combine characteristics of hiking boots and climbing shoes to create versatile footwear that excels in rocky terrain.

Climbing shoes are useless for hiking, and hiking boots aren’t suitable for technical climbing. With sticky rubber outsoles and trail-ready comfort, approach shoes offer the best of both worlds.

In recent years, approach shoes have become an essential tool for climbers, hikers, and ridge-scrambling peak baggers alike. There are many different types of approach shoes, and each has a unique set of strengths and weaknesses. Some approach shoes prioritize technical rock climbing ability, while others are robust enough for backpacking and may even come with a mid-height ankle cuff.

To create this roundup, our team of expert gear testers wore dozens of different approach shoe styles and made meticulous notes about the pros and cons of each. Lead author Austin Beck-Doss is based in Lander, Wyo., where steep muddy treks to sport crags and long slogs to alpine routes provide the ideal approach shoe testing ground.

We’ve organized the best approach shoes on the market into several distinct categories. Whether you need footwear for quick jaunts to the cliff or multi-day slogs through the mountains, our list has you covered.

Scroll through to see all of our recommended buys, and at the end of our list, be sure to check out our buyer’s guide. We’ve also included a chart for side-by-side comparisons, and wrap things up with with some frequently asked questions.

Editor’s Note: We updated this guide on January 2, 2024, to add new shoe recommendations and additional information about our testing process.

The Best Approach Shoes of 2024


Best Overall


La Sportiva TX4 Approach Shoes

Specs

  • Weight
    1 lb., 8 oz. (pair, men’s 9.5)
  • Upper material
    Leather
  • Outsole
    Vibram Megagrip Traverse


The Best Approach Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Supportive

  • Stable

  • Long lasting and durable

Cons

  • The size seems to fluctuates when wet

  • Not the most breathable


Austin Beck-Doss

Best Budget Approach Shoes


Black Diamond Session Suede

Specs

  • Weight
    1 lb., 5 oz. (pair, men’s 9.5)
  • Upper material
    Suede leather
  • Outsole
    Black Diamond Black Label-Street


The Best Approach Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Versatile

  • Trendy appearance

Cons

  • Not ideal for technical climbing

  • Not very supportive


Austin Beck-Doss

Most Durable Approach Shoe


La Sportiva Boulder X

Specs

  • Weight
    2 lbs., 3 oz. (pair, men’s 10)
  • Upper material
    Leather
  • Outsole
    Vibram Megagrip Idro-Grip V Smear


The Best Approach Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Good value

  • Durable

  • Comfortable

Cons

  • Heavy

  • Not the best for fifth-class climbing


Austin Beck-Doss

Best for Light and Fast Approaches


The North Face Cragstone Pro

Specs

  • Weight
    1 lb., 3 oz.
  • Upper material
    Spectra mesh
  • Outsole
    Vibram rubber


The Best Approach Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Breathable

  • Lightweight

  • Easily adjustable fit

Cons

  • Not ideal for foot jamming


Austin Beck-Doss

Best of the Rest


Arc’teryx Konseal FL 2 Leather GTX

Specs

  • Weight
    1 lb., 12 oz. (pair, men’s 9.5)
  • Upper material
    Split-suede leather
  • Outsole
    Vibram Megagrip


The Best Approach Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Durable

  • Capable on technical terrain and cracks

  • Waterproof

Cons

  • Hot

  • Expensive


Austin Beck-Doss


Black Diamond Mission LT 2.0

Specs

  • Weight
    1 lb., 8 oz. (pair, men’s 9.5)
  • Upper material
    Synthetic durable knit
  • Outsole
    Black Diamond Black Label-Mountain


The Best Approach Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Great for long hikes

  • Nice looking

  • Comfortable

Cons

  • Not ideal for fifth-class climbing

  • Requires a short break-in period


Austin Beck-Doss


SCARPA Mescalito

Specs

  • Weight
    1lb. 12.2 oz.
  • Upper Material
    Suede
  • Outsole
    Vibram Megagrip


The Best Approach Shoes of 2024

Pros

  • Durable

  • Sticky

  • Well-equipped for technical climbing

Cons

  • Not the most breathable

  • Expensive


Austin Beck-Doss

Approach Shoe Comparison Table

Approach ShoesPriceWeightUpper MaterialOutsoleBest For
La Sportiva TX4$1591 lb., 8 oz. (pair, men’s 9.5)LeatherVibram Megagrip TraverseTechnical edging and jamming
Black Diamond Session Suede$1501 lb., 5 oz. (pair, men’s 9.5)Suede leatherBlack Diamond Black Label-StreetUrban use and mellow approaches
La Sportiva Boulder X
$1492 lbs., 3 oz. (pair, men’s 10)LeatherVibram Megagrip Idro-Grip V SmearLong-term durability
The North Face Cragstone Pro$1691lb., 3 oz. (pair, men’s 10)Spectra meshVibram LitebaseLight and fast objectives, hot weather
Arc’teryx Konseal FL 2 Leather GTX$2201 lb., 12 oz. (pair, men’s 9.5)Split-suede leatherVibram MegagripScrambling, aid climbing, foot jamming
Black Diamond Mission LT 2.0$1601 lb., 8 oz. (pair, men’s 9.5)Synthetic knitBlack Diamond Black Label-Mountain RubberAll around use
SCARPA Mescalito$2291 lb., 12.2 oz.Suede leatherVibram MegagripTechnical edging and jamming

How We Tested Approach Shoes

Testing all sorts of climbing gear on the glorious limestone of El Potrero Chico; (photo/Hannah Grace Davis)

The GearJunkie team is full of climbers, from weekend dabblers to recovering dirtbags. And, like most modern climbers, approach shoes are a key part of our standard attire. Sticky rubber at the ready, we approach the office, we approach the grocery store, and when we’re lucky, we approach the crag.

To compile this list of recommendations, we checked out a broad spectrum of approach shoe brands and models. We made sure to try shoes from leading brands and smaller upstarts. Lead author Austin Beck-Doss spends most weekends out at the cliff, and he naturally lives in approach shoes as a result. Senior Editor Christ Carter is also an avid escalador with multiple ascents of El Capitan under his belt. Every pair of shoes on this list went through a visual inspection, weight check, and plenty of days out climbing.

There are many different kinds of approach shoes. Some are hefty and technical, and others are light and flimsy. While making our assessments, we considered each shoe’s intended purpose according to the manufacturer. Still, we hiked, scrambled, and climbed vertical rock up to fifth class in every single pair.

Our recommendations are always in flux. As we continue to test new models, we will update this list to include the best of the best.

Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose Approach Shoes

What Are Approach Shoes?

approach shoes
Heading off to the crag in Mexico; (photo/Hannah Grace Davis)

Approach shoes are a cross between hiking shoes and climbing shoes. They combine the best traits of both parent categories to maximize performance between the car and the crag.

Though our list of recommendations includes a broad spectrum of features, approach shoes generally have a few key characteristics. Most importantly, they have a sticky rubber outsole. To earn a place in the “approach” category, a pair of shoes must have some capacity to stick to rock and execute relatively technical movements.

Many approach shoes come with a built-in “climbing zone” — which is a patch of smooth rubber near the toe that can be used to smear and stand on small footholds. Accessing the base of climbing routes often requires fourth or low-fifth-class climbing — this is where approach shoes shine.

Along with durable sticky rubber soles, approach shoes should also have a durable upper and offer some baseline stability. From long slogs on the trail to boulder hopping up talus, approach shoes must put up with serious wear without falling apart. If they’re too flimsy or thin, they probably can’t withstand the abuse that a true approach shoe should. Ultralight trail runners and legitimate approach shoes are not the same.

While hiking shoes tend to have a curved, rocker profile, technical approach shoes usually have a flat sole. A flat sole makes it easier to channel power into your toes and stand on small footholds.

All of the shoes on this list are proper approach shoes. Some are light and nimble, others are super supportive and robust, but they’re all built to meet the needs of climbers on a mission.

Climbing Ability and Outsole

By design, approach shoes are far more suited for technical climbing than hiking shoes. For the most part, the superior grip and climbing ability come from a soft and sticky rubber outsole. As climbers know, super soft, tacky rubber is the ideal material for climbing rock with confidence.

Approach shoes have hybrid outsoles that combine climbing shoe and hiking boot features for maximum versatility. Approach shoe rubber is relatively soft, but it should still maintain traction on the trail.

Approach shoe outsoles
Approach shoe outsoles are made from sticky rubber and feature a smooth “climbing zone” at the toe; (photo/Austin Beck-Doss)

When shopping for climbing shoes, it is important to consider where and how you will use them. If you plan to wear your approach shoes while scrambling on steep terrain and climbing 4th and 5th-class rock, be sure to choose a shoe with soft rubber and an ample climbing zone. If you’ll mostly be hiking on low-angle trails, general performance and comfort should be greater priorities than technical climbing features.

If you are a well-rounded mountain goer, we recommend approach shoes with a customizable fit that you can adjust according to the activity at hand. For maximum customization, look for a lacing system that runs the length of the upper and all the way down to the toe.

On this list, the La Sportiva TX4 is an approach shoe with ultra-impressive technical climbing ability. For moderate terrain and casual multi-pitch days, the Black Diamond Mission LT 2.0 is a good comfort-forward option.

Upper Material: Synthetic or Leather?

A shoe’s upper is the material that makes up the top of the shoe. In the approach shoe category, most uppers are made from either leather or synthetic material. Both options have their pros and cons, and neither is strictly better than the other.

Leather uppers, similar to those found on traditional hiking footwear, offer supreme durability. We’ve long-term tested both leather and synthetic approach shoes, and the leather styles seem to hold up to more rugged use.

Leather also has an advantage when it comes to water resistance. It naturally repels water and doesn’t fully rely on a Durable Water Repellent (DWR) treatment to keep your feet dry.

Scarpa Rapid upper
Synthetic uppers are less durable but far more breathable than leather; (photo/Austin Beck-Doss)

In warm conditions, leather does not breathe especially well and can cause uncomfortable, hot feet. If you plan to wear your approach shoes for desert climbing in places like Joshua Tree or Red Rock, leather may not be the ideal choice.

Leather also stretches, while synthetic does not. If you purchase leather approach shoes, it is important to realize that they will become a bit roomier over time.

On this list, the La Sportiva TX4s have a durable and water-resistant leather upper, whereas the North Face Cragstone Pro features a lightweight and thoroughly breathable synthetic upper.

Durability

Approach shoes are meant to be worn in rugged and rocky terrain, and long-term durability is a must. In our experience, the upper materials on approach shoes wear out long before the rubber outsoles do.

As the outsole wears, the tread becomes smooth and shallow, but the shoes can typically go on functioning without issue. Plus, many approach shoes can be resoled. When the upper falls apart, however, the shoes no longer function as needed.

When climbing on rock or standing in aid ladders, the toe-end of approach shoes take a lot of abuse. Most shoes on this list have a sticky rubber rand that wraps up and over the toe which adds durability in a key area — just about all of the longest-lasting styles have it.

If durability is a priority for you, we recommend a pair of heavy-duty approach shoes with a rubber toe rand and a leather upper. Leather does get warm in summer conditions, but it also tends to last longer than synthetic material. On this list, the La Sportiva Boulder X is an impressively durable and long-lasting approach shoe.

Support and Stiffness

Climbing gear is heavy, and hauling a fully loaded backpack calls for supportive footwear. Backpackers tend to wear stiff and supportive boots for stability, and in many ways, climbers have similar needs.

Additionally, stiff shoes tend to work better for standing on small edges and climbing cracks. Aid climbers also tend to prefer stiff shoes — standing in slings is downright painful in floppy shoes. On this list, the La Sportiva TX4 is on the very stiff end of the approach shoe spectrum.

Aid climbing in approach shoes.
Aid climbing is tough on the feet. Sturdy approach shoes are essential; (photo/Austin Beck-Doss)

Not all approach shoes are stiff and supportive. While super stiff shoes may be nice while hiking with a full rack and a rope, they have some downsides.

Firstly, stiff shoes sacrifice agility and flex, which can come in handy while scampering up a talus field or soloing an easy approach pitch. If you’re looking for a soft and nimble approach shoe, check out the Black Diamond Session Suede.

Style

Approach shoes are built for the outdoors, but many climbers choose to rock them as their go-to, do-it-all footwear. While aesthetics aren’t the main purpose of approach shoes, some recent styles have become quite spiffy.

Approaching the grocery store in the Black Diamond Session Suede.
Some approach shoes — like the Black Diamond Session Suede — are great for walking to the crag … and the grocery store; (photo/Austin Beck-Doss)

On this list, shoes like the Black Diamond Session Suede have a lightweight profile and modern styling that looks great in the climbing gym and other front country settings.

Value

Approach shoes vary in price from about $60 to over $200. However, an approach shoe’s value is not purely based on the price. The less expensive shoes on this list are great in many ways, but they won’t last as long or perform as well on rugged approaches. For the best overall bang for your buck, check out the La Sportiva Boulder X.

Approach shoe sticky rubber in action.,
Sticky rubber is magic; (photo/Austin Beck-Doss)

Weight and Packability

When multi-pitch climbing, it is common to clip a pair of approach shoes to your harness to wear while rappelling or hiking back to the base of the route. For this reason, we love it when approach shoes are light and packable.

Light shoes come in handy, but it’s important to maintain a balance between total weight, performance, and durability. Super light approach shoes like The North Face Cragstone Pro are not the most stable or long-lasting. Burly and stiff shoes like the La Sportiva Boulder X can foot jam beautifully, but they take up lots of space on a harness.

If you’re looking for a good middle ground, the Black Diamond Mission LT 2.0 is light and fairly supportive. On the other hand, if you’re looking for something that you can just clip to your haul loop and forget about, the Session Suede weighs just over 1 pound per pair. Plus, the heel collapses down so they’ll take up less space on your harness.

FAQ

What is the difference between hiking shoes and approach shoes?

Hiking and approach shoes are similar, but there are a handful of key characteristics that differentiate the two categories. While hiking shoes are designed for waking on relatively flat surfaces, approach shoes are made to venture into rocky and technical terrain.

In general, approach shoes have a flat sole with a soft and sticky rubber outsole that is similar to a climbing shoe. The soft rubber conforms to rock and provides lots of friction when smearing or edging. Hiking shoes tend to have a rockered profile and a harder rubber compound that prioritizes durability and works well on dirt and mud.

Approach shoes have semi-shallow tread patterns that are far less aggressive than the deep lugs of most hiking shoes. While climbing or scrambling over rock, shallow tread maximizes surface contact and increases friction.

Many approach shoes have a “climbing zone,” which is a completely flat plane of sticky rubber underneath the toe. This feature is great for climbing rock, but it can also be a detriment while hiking through mud or sand.

Ultimately, there is a lot of overlap between hiking and approach shoes. In many cases, you could use hiking shoes as approach shoes and vice versa.

Which approach shoes are best for technical climbing?

The shoes don’t make the climber. The climbing ability of any shoe depends on the skillset and comfort level of the user. With that said, all of the approach shoes on this list are designed to handle technical, rocky terrain. Some, however, are far more capable than others.

Of the numerous shoes that we tested, the La Sportiva TX4 has the most impressive climbing ability.

Can I run in approach shoes?

Not all approach shoes are designed for running. Many of the shoes on this list are simply too stiff and too heavy to work well at high speeds. If you’re looking for approach shoes that can double as trail runners, check out The North Face Cragstone Pro.

Weighing in at only 1 pound, 5 ounces, the Cragstone looks and feels like a mountain running shoe. When it comes time to scramble or smear, the SCARPA Rapid’s sticky outsole and generous climbing zone are plenty capable.

What are the best budget approach shoes?

If you’re looking for great value without sacrificing technical ability, check out the La Sportiva Boulder X.


<img width="2400" height="1600" src="http://mindflight.me/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/DSC02436-2-scaled-e1684443551990.jpg" class="attachment-w575:383 size-w575:383 not-transparent wp-post-image" alt="The Best Hiking Pants for Men of 2024" decoding="async" sizes="90px" srcset="http://mindflight.me/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/DSC02436-2-scaled-e1684443551990.jpg 2400w, https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/images.gearjunkie.com/uploads/2023/05/DSC02436-2-scaled-e1684443551990-300×200.jpg 300w, https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/images.gearjunkie.com/uploads/2023/05/DSC02436-2-scaled-e1684443551990-700×467.jpg 700w, https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/images.gearjunkie.com/uploads/2023/05/DSC02436-2-scaled-e1684443551990-768×512.jpg 768w, https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/images.gearjunkie.com/uploads/2023/05/DSC02436-2-scaled-e1684443551990-1536×1024.jpg 1536w, https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/images.gearjunkie.com/uploads/2023/05/DSC02436-2-scaled-e1684443551990-2048×1365.jpg 2048w, https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/images.gearjunkie.com/uploads/2023/05/DSC02436-2-scaled-e1684443551990-720×480.jpg 720w" data-has-transparency="false" data-dominant-color="4b474b" style="" data-attachment-id="243039" data-permalink="https://gearjunkie.com/dsc02436-2" data-orig-file="http://mindflight.me/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/DSC02436-2-scaled-e1684443551990.jpg" data-orig-size="2400,1600" data-comments-opened="0" data-image-meta="{"aperture":"1.4","credit":"","camera":"ILCE-7M4","caption":"","created_timestamp":"1678823500","copyright":"","focal_length":"24","iso":"1600","shutter_speed":"0.0003125","title":"","orientation":"1"}" data-image-title="Best Men’s Hiking Pants, DSC02436 2" data-image-description="" data-image-caption="

Testing hiking pants along the Great Divide Trail in Tennessee; (photo/Honey McNaughton)

” data-medium-file=”https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/images.gearjunkie.com/uploads/2023/05/DSC02436-2-scaled-e1684443551990-300×200.jpg” data-large-file=”https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/images.gearjunkie.com/uploads/2023/05/DSC02436-2-scaled-e1684443551990-700×467.jpg” />

Hiking


The Best Hiking Pants for Men of 2024

With a focus on comfort, durability, and performance, we’ve found the best hiking pants for men. Get ready to hit the trail.


<img width="2560" height="1928" src="http://mindflight.me/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/PXL_20230630_234455528.PORTRAIT-1-scaled-1.jpg" class="no-lazyload not-transparent wp-post-image" alt="The Best Hiking Socks of 2024" decoding="async" sizes="90px" srcset="http://mindflight.me/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/PXL_20230630_234455528.PORTRAIT-1-scaled-1.jpg 2560w, https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/images.gearjunkie.com/uploads/2023/07/PXL_20230630_234455528.PORTRAIT-1-300×226.jpg 300w, https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/images.gearjunkie.com/uploads/2023/07/PXL_20230630_234455528.PORTRAIT-1-700×527.jpg 700w, https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/images.gearjunkie.com/uploads/2023/07/PXL_20230630_234455528.PORTRAIT-1-768×578.jpg 768w, https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/images.gearjunkie.com/uploads/2023/07/PXL_20230630_234455528.PORTRAIT-1-1536×1157.jpg 1536w, https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/images.gearjunkie.com/uploads/2023/07/PXL_20230630_234455528.PORTRAIT-1-2048×1542.jpg 2048w" data-has-transparency="false" data-dominant-color="746d5f" style="" data-attachment-id="256774" data-permalink="https://gearjunkie.com/?attachment_id=256774" data-orig-file="http://mindflight.me/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/PXL_20230630_234455528.PORTRAIT-1-scaled-1.jpg" data-orig-size="2560,1928" data-comments-opened="0" data-image-meta="{"aperture":"1.85","credit":"","camera":"Pixel 6","caption":"","created_timestamp":"1688143495","copyright":"","focal_length":"6.81","iso":"38","shutter_speed":"0.00083","title":"","orientation":"1"}" data-image-title="PXL_20230630_234455528.PORTRAIT" data-image-description="" data-image-caption="

(photo/Andrew Potter)

” data-medium-file=”https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/images.gearjunkie.com/uploads/2023/07/PXL_20230630_234455528.PORTRAIT-1-300×226.jpg” data-large-file=”https://s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/images.gearjunkie.com/uploads/2023/07/PXL_20230630_234455528.PORTRAIT-1-700×527.jpg” />

Hiking


The Best Hiking Socks of 2024

Get ready to hit the trail with the best hiking socks of 2024. From epic thru-hikes to quick day hikes, we have you covered.

The post The Best Approach Shoes of 2024 appeared first on GearJunkie.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *